Fiction
allows true aspects of LDS experience to be depicted in a light-hearted,
humorous way that could be more difficult to accomplish in non-fiction. This is
seen repeatedly in Doug Thayer’s novel: Will
Wonders Never Cease. The principle of chastity is a big focus of many youth
lessons and talks by leaders of the LDS church. This is conveyed in the novel
through Lucille’s determined and constant efforts to teach Kyle, and other
youth, sex-ed. She holds ward sex-ed meetings, she makes Kyle look up sexual words
in the dictionary and discuss them with her and when she attends the 6th
grade sex talk with him, she finds it to be woefully uninformative. This
preoccupation with chastity is ingrained in Mormon culture and depicted in a
somewhat humorous, exaggerated way in Thayer’s novel. It illustrates an
authentic part of Mormon beliefs and youth life, while also making such a
serious, heavy topic more approachable. And although it pokes some fun at this
overzealousness, Kyle is also seen as a little grateful for this education
because he doesn’t have the same confusion as his friends.
In
the non-fiction genre, writers have to stick closely to the facts of a
situation and leave out exaggerations. Additionally, in non-fiction writing
such as a personal essay, writers may find it difficult to include personal
flaws or the less flattering aspects of the church. The same perceptions that
would be relatable and funny from fictional character may come across as
deprecating or critical when expressed by a faithful member of the church,
especially to a non-member audience. Also, personal essay writers may not want
to offend those close to them by disclosing their unfiltered perceptions and
judgments. Kyle, on the other hand, is allowed to share his unfiltered thoughts
and comment on his mother, father, brothers and friends without fear of giving
offence because he is a fictional character, not a real person consciously
sharing a life experience.
I definitely agree that it is easier to point out flaws humorously in fictional works, and just easier to bring them up in general. I found that when writing my personal essay I was constantly having to battle with how far to go, especially since I wrote about family members, and anything I say is also clearly a reflection on me. In fiction, the writer has more of a buffer from the reader in that way.
ReplyDelete