Before I begin my review I would like
to discuss my thoughts on fictional stories and religion. I don’t think they go
together. I don’t they were meant to. I don’t think our minds can
intellectually read them. A fictional story on the doctrines of a church was
never meant to be. And Nephi Andserson’s novel, Added Upon proved that. The idea
was sweet and charming. Different characters on a journey through the plan of
salvation. How sweet, even when looking past the poorly written dialogue. But, doctrines
of church’s are believed to be true! So. . . why would we try and write
[FICTIONAL] stories on true beliefs? As a reader I feel that fictional stories
discredit churches doctrine because it stands strong enough on its own. Back to
what I said, writing fictional stories in relation to doctrine is hard when
trying to be successful. This is because I think it ruins something that has
already been perfectly written, doctrine.
Now my review.
Ups: I think this book challenges us as
readers to ask all the right questions and give this idea (after life- pre life
etc…) a longer thought. This was definitely a book that guided me in the right
direction searching for the truth and the knowledge to understand God’s plan
for me and his children. I can also see how this story can help readers who don’t
understand the LDS’s beliefs of the Plan of Salvation to compare it to their
own lives or to others.
Downs: From my last sentence from my Up’s
I want to say this novel can also confuse readers who don’t understand the LDS’s
beliefs of the Plan of Salvation because I think Anderson didn’t do a great job
convey through his characters what LDS members truly believe. His characters
acted on obedience when as members we act on faith, which is what helps us to
obey. The writing and character development was sad but easily overlooked
because I knew where he was trying to get at as a member of the LDS church.
No comments:
Post a Comment